Facebook Twitter YouTube RSS
Home World A breakaway isn’t far away
formats

A breakaway isn’t far away

Published on September 16, 2011 by in World

The modern game is a completely different beast to the one of even 10 years ago and despite football’s governing bodies attempting to control it; the owners of the big clubs now possess pretty much all the power. It is these people who control our beloved teams and can run them as they see fit. It can’t be long before these money obsessed businessmen attempt to breakaway from the domestic leagues and form a, no, The European Super League.

Football has become one of the most lucrative investments in the world and has attracted interest from some of the richest and most powerful people from across the global in the last decade. From the Glazer empire who own Premier League champions Manchester United to the Qatari Royal Family who now own Malaga CF in Spain, the influence is growing by the year which in turn limits the effectiveness of FIFA, CONMEBAL and UEFA; never mind the national football associations. The new financial restraints introduced by UEFA which come into affect from the start of next season will have little effect on the top clubs.

It has long been assumed that sooner or later football would fall foul financially due to the huge amount being invested and spent within the game. It is absurd that Manchester United can continue to announce record profits every year when everyone knows how much the Glazer family owe the banks. When these figures are announced the small print at the bottom actually states how these figures effect the overall financial state of the club but the headlines are all that is reported. Two years ago, one big club announced record profits; it was only in the final paragraph that they actually stated they were still heavily in debt.

The start of the 2011/12 season was delayed in Italy and Spain due to financial issues. The top clubs in each country have a monopoly over the revenue that the league generates which ensures their ability to remain at the top and decreases the chances of smaller teams ever challenging for the major honours. The opening weekends of the Premier League season in England have seen the two Manchester sides demolish their nearest rivals and almost guarantee that it is a two way fight for the title this season. In Spain, La Liga will be won by Barcelona or Real Madrid and we knew that long before a ball was even kicked.

Once upon a time the Scottish League was written off because only Celtic or Rangers could ever win it. This has actually now spread throughout the major leagues in Europe and you can predict who will win almost every league from just a small handful of hopefuls in every nation. Whilst supporters of the top sides gloat gleefully about how successful they are, the smaller clubs face an eternal struggle to survive.

The gap in quality in domestic leagues is also diminishing with every passing year too. The Premier League advertises itself as the best league in the world when realistically the overall standard is decreasing year on year. Whilst you can argue there are now five teams that could win the league everyone truly knows it will be between two. Thus, there are about 12 teams who will slug it out all year in order to retain their TV money to ensure the happiness of the chairman. There can be little issue taken with football being run as a business but when profit is held as the ultimate goal from the season, something has been lost that will never return.

The whole reason many people play, and participate in sport is in an attempt to win/be successful. The Olympic motto, which defines all sport, is ‘citius, altius, fortius’ – ‘faster, higher, and stronger’. In years gone by it was also fun to simply compete, however, those times are gone now. Everything has become about winning and trying to maximise profits.

It is rather vulgar that in times of a recession football clubs are still gloating about how much money fans invested in season tickets, or rather how much money they have conned out of supporters.

In 2000 the elite clubs formed a group called the G14 which terrified the governing bodies. They feared that the top clubs could breakaway and set up their own European Super League where they would have no say on how things were managed. This actually lead to Michel Platini pleading with them to come back to FIFA and UEFA in return for guaranteed insurance if players were to get injured whilst on international duty. Whilst this appeased many of the member clubs they still set up the European Club Association.

Domestic football is becoming less and less appealing for the supporters of clubs with no realistic chance of success. The new people running football will soon not be interested in travelling within their country if there is a possibility of entertaining sides like Barcelona and Milan every week. Although many football fans oppose the idea it could be more appealing to pay for a season ticket if you are guaranteed to see some of the best players in the world every week. When you consider that Arsenal fans have had to pay 6.1% extra this season and have seen two of their best players sold it would almost certainly be more appealing.

We live in a world where people want everything on demand and insist on getting value for money. The Champions League offers some particularly interesting first round games but the predictability is starting to affect the game as a whole. The set up requires modification and change if the game is to remain as popular and as affluent.

Whether we admit it or not it is the leading teams that will decide the future of our game and in truth a European Super League would probably improve the overall quality of the game at the elite level as well as re-establishing the game domestically with real and proper competition.

 
 Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Reddit Share on LinkedIn
7 Comments  comments 

7 Responses

  1. Simon Furnivall

    Great piece, Andy. The idea of a European Super League is something I hate, but I agree that it is edging ever closer. The game, more than ever, is run for the sake of profit (just look at how FIFA treat the World Cup) and if there is more profit to be had in a Super League than a domestic league, then it is almost certainly a matter of when, rather than if it happens.

  2. Thanks Simon, I too dislike the idea of a European Super League but it is inevitable. The way the game is going it needs the elite clubs being tested every week to maintain the levels and retain the support.

    However, I am still very unsure about how you gain qualification and separate from your own domestic league??

  3. Simon Furnivall

    I expect that it would be a closed shop without any promotion/relegation (if you’re going to set up a league for the sole reason of profit maximisation, why add the risk of relegation?) and it would simply be the 18 or 20 most powerful clubs. But such a breakaway would leave some very big clubs behind.

  4. I think that the key issue. If a big side has a bad season would they then be excluded? What would happen for instance with Malaga now? There are so many open questions that remain and I feel it will be almost impossible to please everyone.

  5. Josh Longmuir

    I’ve long thought that some form of franchise system (similar to that used in the US and even the rugby league Super League inthe UK) would be the most likely way for a European Super League to be created. It would be widely derided by football traditionalists however as the article points out the key driver would be money and who cares about tradition when there’s more money to be made?! 20 places, say, in a new league could be offered and clubs then given the opportunity to bid for them based on revenue, average attendance, shirt sales, e.t.c as has been pointed out I can’t see clubs agreeing to a promotion/delegation system (especially if you were a club like Rangers) as they would want to guarantee their place on the basis whatever they perceived that they would be “offering” to the super league in return.

  6. First of all; this is a really interesting read Andy. Fabulous stuff and a pleasure to read through.

    You also throw up the major drive behind any desire to start-up a European Super League – money.

    It will boil down to money. If the top clubs don’t think they are making enough profit in their domestic leagues; it will happen. A whisper will turn into an idea. An idea will turn into a plan; and a plan will drive sponsorship deals through the roof.

    I even think it could happen on a global level with the Middle-East, perhaps the Cosmos and even a Far-East team getting involved; especially if they are going to welcome the likes of Manchester United, Barcelona, Real Madrid and Liverpool to their respective regions for competitive games.

    The details of such a league probably need to be worked out by people much greedier than us but I don’t actually see many reasons why it couldn’t end up a two-tier “locked” system. Two divisions but with clubs unlikely to drop from the lower tier unless they wish to give up their spot; fail to make enough money.

    Anyway; yes. Fascinating read Andy.

  7. elp

    you mention that the G-14 scared UEFA or FIFA? because i do remember Sep Blatter scoffing at them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>